Saturday, March 19, 2022

Social Media: Empowering and Leveller Requires Regulatory Measures

          

  A few days back Congress leader Sonia Gandhi read out a statement in the Lok Sabha about the negative role being played by social media like Facebook, Twitter and Utube etc.  In fact, social media has been spreading all sorts of concocted and baseless stories more against the ruling dispensation than the opposition parties. Social media in India has been known to be Hindu phobic but that does not mean that it should be subjected to a blanket ban. Every type of mass media, be it electronic, print, digital or social is susceptible to misuse and that has been happening for a long time. Therefore, some regulatory measures would be welcome to make it more responsible and accountable. However, if we compare the advantages of social media it outweighs by far more than the disadvantages. The biggest advantage of social media is that it is the best leveller, and it has empowered the common and deprived sections of society. Before the advent of social media only those having access could enjoy or relish the fruits of the freedom of expression but now even a poor person, without having any resources, can create sensations, thanks to social media.

  The credit for it goes only and only to the Technology, not to any person or government. In fact, the whole world has changed after the invention of GOOGLE. Thus, the Media is divided between – Before Google (BG) and After Google (AG).  Think of any subject of the world and plenty of information about that is available on Google, that too, in a jiffy. During the recent elections of UP and other states, we have seen that every Tom, Dick, and Harry became a journalist and was not preparing the news as it was but as per the dictates of those, who paid them. Many of these flies by night journalists, without any training or ethics, were bribed to prepare the reports,  to the likings and benefits of their paymasters.

    Because of the proliferation of social media, some anarchists have found their easy tools to create confusion. This media was also able to a great extent to sway even the mainstream media is playing up the communalism and casteism. Regrettably, the issues which should have been discussed by the media were ignored mainly because of the corrupt media. It is always easy for politicians to purvey lies through social media than any other media.

 Be that as it may, it must be said in the same breath that in this era of powerful social media, it is easy to spread fake news. But it is equally true that fake news can also be exposed with Godspeed provided proper regulatory measures are framed.  

 

Tuesday, March 15, 2022

Nitish Kumar Must Apologise to the speaker for his Uncouth behaviour

 

 It was a very sad and unfortunate spectacle to see the Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar livid with rage against Assembly speaker Vijay Kumar Sinha yesterday on the floor of the House. Nitish Kumar is known for being a sober politician but the way he behaved with Speaker Shri Sinha was reprehensible, highly unbecoming of the leader of the house and deserves to be condemned in the strongest possible terms. In fact, after the verbal humiliation that was heaped on him by the leader of the house, Shri Sinha has lost all moral authority to continue in the post he is holding. If he has even an iota of self-respect, he must tender his resignation from the post of the Speaker. It is being reported that terribly hurt by the insult, he did not attend the house today. 
Why was Nitish Kumar so provoked and enraged that he forgot the basic courtesy towards the Speaker and started openly fulminating against him despite many requests from him to calm down and listen to him? Nobody knows the exact reason for losing his control but it is certain that Nitish Kumar has done irreparable damage to the institution of the Speaker. Shri Kumar was visibly shivering with rage against the Speaker but that is not done in a democratic set-up. Even if Shri Nitish Kumar had any grievance against Shri Sinha, he should have privately discussed the issue in the chamber of the Speaker and resolved the same. In fact, in Parliamentary democracy, the Speaker of either the Lok Sabha or assemblies is the highest authority of the house as he/ she presides over the meetings and is the custodian of the House. The highest respect must be shown towards any Presiding Officers even if he/she is not the Speaker or Chairperson of the House. Anybody, howsoever high and mighty he/she may be is expected to show respect to the post of the Speaker/ Chairperson. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha is elected under Article 93, and he/she can be removed by resolution under Article 94 of the Constitution. Similarly, the Speaker of the Assembly is elected under Article 178 of the Constitution of India and can be removed by resolution under Article 179 of the Constitution.
The Constitution provides the highest dignity to the office of the Speaker. So much so, the Speaker can haul up even the judges of the High Court and the Supreme Court if any impeachment proceeding is initiated against the Justices. The speaker cannot be summoned by any court of law. The historic cases of 'Keshav Singh of UP Assembly' or 'Pandit MSM Sharma versus Sri Krishna Sinha and another' have clearly delineated the powers and privileges of the Speaker.  In the recent past the then Speaker of the Lok Sabha Somnath Chatterjee had refused to even accept the notice of the Supreme Court in the petition filed in the Raja Ram Pal Sigh case related to the disqualification of some MPs. Thus, the primacy of the office of the Speaker in the Lok Sabha and the Assemblies is undisputed and beyond any reproach. 
It is very strange that Nitish Kumar who has a very long parliamentary career was yesterday behaving with an Assembly speaker like a cheap and rowdy politician. The least that he can do now is to restore the dignity to the office of the Speaker by publicly apologising to the Speaker on the floor of the house and instead of washing the dirty linens against any constitutional authority, he must set an example of equanimity by paying respect to them at least in public.

Saturday, March 12, 2022

Historic Victory of Yogi has Broken Many Myths and Superstitions


Yogi Adityanath has broken many myths in the UP-Assembly elections. He has successfully cast aside the superstition that any Chief Minister who visits NOIDA would soon lose the chair. Yogi has visited NOIDA many times as the Chief Minister and yet he has led his party to a spectacular win in the assembly elections. Those who have been spreading and perpetuating this myth are, in fact, the enemies of science and the scientific temper. Unfortunately, the opponents of Yogi and Modi have been very vocal in proliferating this myth. Because of this fallacy, Mayawati and Akhilesh never ventured to visit NOIDA during their Chief Ministership, yet they lost their chairs. As a matter of fact, they have been foremost in drilling this superstition among the minds of the people, little knowing that such credulities often cause huge damage to them.
The second big myth that has been broken by Yogi ji is that no Chief Minister, who has led his party to power continuously for five years, has returned to power after the elections. Even Pandit Govind Ballabh Pant and Dr Sampurnand could not complete their term of five years, although in their times there was not even the slightest doubt of the Congress coming back to power. But after 1985 no party or leader has been repeated to power in elections. Yogi Adityanath has thus, made a history, who not only remained in power for five years but has led to the stunning victory for himself and the party in the assembly elections.
Yogi Adityanath is a Sanyasi-king (Chief Minister) like that of Raja Janak of Mithila, who is known as Rajarshi. Raja Janak was an ascetic with a family, whereas Yogi has not only renounced his own family but has embraced the entire state as his family.
The third myth that he has broken is that of the MY (Muslim- Yadav) factor and has got replaced it with another MY (Modi-Yogi) factor. In the second type of MY, he has got support from all communities, even from Yadavas also but Muslims voted against him with all vigour and vehemence. Yogi administration has extended all facilities like; free ration, Kisan Samman Nidhi and other benefits without any discrimination against any caste but due to the toxicity of communalism, Muslims failed to see any goodness in Modi-Yogi.
The fourth myth has been that without the support of goondas, nobody could think of winning the elections, but Yogi romped back home without taking any help from the goondas and mafia dons, albeit he took them head-on. Hopefully, in his second term, YOGI will further consolidate the good works done by him and set many more new records and role models of the government without fear, favour or ill-will towards anyone.

Wednesday, March 9, 2022

Russia- Ukraine War: Throttling of Information by Western Media and Fascination for Half-baked Medical Degrees by Young Indians


Russia- Ukraine war has thrown two surprises before us. One is the enormity of Indian students, who go to Ukraine for medical education when the whole world knows that it is grossly sub-standard? In fact, the medical degrees of only Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States of America is recognised and valid in India and the medical graduates from other countries including Russia and China have to get through the Foreign Medical Graduate Examination (FMGE) conducted by the National Board Examination (NBE) to become a qualified medical doctor. I personally know a person who holds a medical degree from a country, which was once part of the USSR. He has been working as a Compounder in a Hospital because he has not been able to clear through the FMGE even after three attempts, the maximum limit provided by the NBE.
There appear to be two reasons for this. One is that anyone having resources can go and get admission in medical colleges of Russia, Ukraine, China and some other countries. They are not required to clear even the basic scrutiny to get admissions. Doctors are still in great demand in our country, even if they are no better than quacks. In India, admissions are given by clearing the NEET, although the caste reservations sometimes compromise the quality still, they are far better than those coming from these countries where half-baked medical education is imparted.
Secondly, Medical education in these countries is comparatively cheaper. The students who have obtained degrees from these countries can, at least, rest assured of getting some jobs or can even start their own practice, where rules can be moulded by greasing the palms of corrupt officials. Even in Mumbai and Delhi, such clinics can be found where the Board of any qualified Doctor is hung/displayed but any unqualified assistant prescribes medicines and administers them.
This can be seen to be believed particularly in pathological laboratories, where a technician makes the report on the letterhead already signed by the Pathologist. Since Allopathy is more profitable, most of the Homeopaths and Ayurvedic doctors prescribe and give English medicine (a euphemism for Allopathic medicines). They forget that by doing so, they do more disservice to the stream of medicine, in which they are trained and qualified but also to the people, who approach them for Ayurveda or Homeopathic medicines.
The Government of India has done a very splendid and commendable job by evacuating rather extricating nearly twenty thousand students, who were caught in the war-torn zone, which has been facing heavy shelling day and night. It was at the request of the Indian Prime Minister that the Russian and Ukrainian leaders agreed to give safe passage to these students. It was a Herculean task by all means. Think of those days, when our government miserably failed to take out five lakh Kashmiri Pandits from its own land of Kashmir, when they suffered deaths and dishonour at the hands of barbarians.
The second big surprise is that despite being the superpower the information that is being fed to the whole world is only through western media. The other side of the story has been blacked out. In all wars truth is the biggest casualty but, in this war, the other side found no mention. Needless to say, western media is notorious for disseminating only such news as suits them. British and American media have always been mischievously giving highly skewed and coloured news and the same is happening with the Ukraine Russia war. And no one knows about it more than most of the Indians but the irony in India is that there is no dearth of such journalists who are ready to be sold out for some bucks and work as per the callings and dictates of their paymasters.
The Government of India and the conscientious people of the country will, therefore, have to give a fresh look in formulating a credible and robust policy so that our media houses could be able to give independent, objective and nation-centric news, not the person or party-centric information. Apart from it, some screening should be done of those students who waste a lot of precious foreign exchange and return to the country with practically no knowledge of medicine and medical science.

Thursday, February 24, 2022

Why is no Muslim found to be a Kabirpanthi?


I have visited Maghar only twice, although it is only 25 Kilometres away from Gorakhpur, where I go almost every year to my in-law’s house. This place is famous because it is associated with the great saint Kabirdas. This place was earlier in the Basti District but now it falls in Sant Kabir Nagar, which has been named after him at the bank of the Aami river. A few years ago, it was a neglected place but now a lot of developments have taken place and many more are underway mainly after the visit of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the UP-Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.

Sant Kabir was a revolutionary, not only by perception but also by practice. He had hit hard on the superstitious practices of both Hindus and Muslims. He is believed to have lived for 125 years and in the last days of his life, he left Kashi to live in Maghar. 'क्या काशी क्या ऊसर मगहर, राम हृदय बस मोरा| जो कासी तन तजै कबीरा, रामे कौन निहोरा' It is said that those who die in Kashi, go to Heaven but those who die in Maghar, are condemned to Hell. Kabir openly said that he did want to take any favour from that God, who differentiates the people because of one’s place of birth or death.

The general belief was that Sant Kabir was loved and followed by Hindus and Muslims as well. It is said that after his death Hindus wanted to cremate his body, but Muslims wanted it to be buried. A quarrel between the two ensued but in the meantime, there was an Akashwani that his dead body had been reduced into flowers. When the shroud was removed, both communities found flowers strewn in place of his body which they got divided among themselves. While Hindus made a Samadhi of those flowers, Muslims made a Mazar. Samadhi and Mazar are found at less than 25 metres in Maghar. While Samadhi is taken care of by a Kabirpanthi Sanyasi, who normally wears white clothes, Mazar is looked after by a Mutwalli. Thus, there was an enigma attached to the death of Sant Kabir, it continues to be even today.

When Hindus and Muslims both lay their claims over Sant Kabirdas, is it not strange as to why no Muslim is found to be a Kabirpanthi, at least to my knowledge? Go to any Ashram or Mutt in any part of the world, it is well-nigh impossible to find any Muslim rejecting and renouncing the religious practices of Islam and following in the footsteps of Kabir Das. This shows that Kabirpanth and Islam cannot go together as anybody rejecting the tenets of Islam will immediately be declared Kafir. But it hardly matters for a Hindu. In fact, a Hindu rejoices if the evils of his/ her religion are often ridiculed or mocked. ‘मोको कहां ढूढ़ें बंदे, मैं तो तेरे पास में. न मैं देवल, न मैं मस्जिद, न काबे कैलास में was liked by Hindus and not by other communities.’ Kabir can provide the best solution to get society rid of religious bigotry.

Any great person’s life remains enveloped with mysteries and so was the life of Kabir. He was lapped up by millions of Hindus throughout the world for assailing the superstitions of their religion but there is hardly any person born as a Mohammedan can be found to be a follower of Kabirdas ji. Kabir Das, Ravi Das, Baba Gorakh Nath or Guru Nanak were the reformers of the Hindu religion. Alas! Those born and brought up in Islam do not subscribe to these seers and saints. A lot of catholicity and tolerance will have to be developed in Islam and Christianity if they start looking at the religion from the prism of Sant Kabir.

 

Tuesday, February 15, 2022

Galloping Progress of New Media

                     Galloping Progress of New Media

 The age-old principle of journalism has been to make headings short and attractive so that the reader, audience, or viewer may get interested in the news. The INTRO i.e., the introduction should be crispy, and it should be able to convey the gist of the news at the beginning itself. In the 'Body', details used to be given and the 'Tail' was considered to be the least important. But nowadays 'Tail' has assumed the highest importance. Today we find that most of the Youtubers, many of them have been former journalists, have totally forgotten old rules. Most of the time is now wasted in the preamble itself and the kernel of the information comes in the last.

    More often than not, it is seen that there is a complete mismatch in the heading and the news. Even if one has read or seen the complete news or video, one is lost in finding out the grains from the chaffs.  It is true that the present generation of journalists is more techno-savvy, more educated and intelligent than the old generation. If proper training is imparted to them, they can work wonders in the field.

   There is no doubt that some web portals have come up, which serve the news in a few words but then their zeal to make the news short usually leave the reader or viewer gasping because nothing becomes clear. Journalism has never been considered to be a lucrative profession. Previously it was confined to the print medium, which has now become a shrunk medium. Audio-electronic media has also lost much of its sheen.

  It appears that the bright future is in store for Webs, YouTube, Blogs, and a whole host of new media. But the million-dollar question is that of the economic viability.  Would a new journalist be able to survive without the support of advertisements? As per OSH Code, the journalists of the new media have also been recognised. 

  Communication technology is making giant strides with every passing day, and it is certain that in the days to come journalism will witness the complete transformation. Hopefully, it will be a welcome change. As far as fake news is concerned, it has always been present. The only difference is that today it has got a bigger reach and therefore has become more damaging. Earlier people used to consider the printed words as the gospel of truth but today every news is taken with a pinch of salt.

 

Sunday, February 13, 2022

Hijab Row is Totally Absurd

                                                                           

        Hijab controversy is raging in the country. Ideally, there should be no objection to what one wears if it does not violate decency and decorum. Modern Muslim feminists like Wafa Sultan, Ayan Hirsi Ali have, in fact, been campaigning against those Islamic orthodoxies, which are retrogressive.  They have said unequivocally in their books that any type of veil is retrogressive and, therefore, the earlier this practice is eschewed by the Muslim women the better. However, presently society appears to have got divided along religious lines.  Even those, who have till yesterday been opposing the dictates of Taliban for women to compulsorily wear veils and not to venture out of their houses without the company of any male member have come now out in support of the Hijab and Burqa for women. Sudden change in their attitudes may be intriguing but those who have closely watched them in the last few years would never be surprised. Anyway, the matter is now sub-judice and hopefully, the ruling of the High Court will settle this issue.

  The moot question is whether Hijab or Burqa are essential and integral parts of the religion or simply a symbol of a distinct identity. There is no doubt that it is now being used as a new phenomenon for asserting religiosity. Earlier it was being worn by a few women, that too, under the pressure of their menfolk but now it has become a politico-religious tool. Men and women of different communities and areas, of course, have been wearing such traditional clothes which could make them different and distinct from the people of other places. Even the persons belonging to the same religion have been wearing different types of dresses. This has been the beauty of our diversity. For example, the style of wearing a Dhoti by Brahmin differentiates him from the ways of wearing by a Kshatriya or Vaishya or other castes. The style of wearing a Lungi of a Panjabi is distinct from a Keralite. A Bengali’s dhoti looks separate from a Rajasthani or UPian or Bihari.

Thus, in a way the trousers or pants have brought a welcome change among men and as it has proved to be a big equaliser. Saris are also worn in different ways by women across the country. A Bengali’s style is district from those of Marathi or other places. But Burqa is a regimented dress as it has come from abroad. It denies any scope of diversity regardless of area or region.  

  In our university days, we have seen Buddhist students coming from Thailand, Sri Lanka and Burma, who used to wear a loose saffron robe or habit by which they could be easily recognised. But it was meant only for monks and not for levity. Although some Muslim boys, not all, have been wearing long Kurtas and short pyjamas, which also gave them a separate recognition. But this freedom has been available only after the higher secondary level. It was impossible to see any burqa-clad girl in any school, college, or university except in Madrassas. Burqa has been considered to be a symbol of bondage and most of the educated girls have been vociferously raising their voices to get rid of this bondage.

  It is now clear that girls in Karnataka and elsewhere have not taken this decision to wear Burqa or hijab on their own. They m have reportedly been instigated or radicalised to take up such a retrogressive step by the Campus Front of India an outfit of the People’s Front of India, which has its roots in Kerala. Obviously, the Hindu boys took the steps of wearing the saffron scarf in reaction, which also cannot be endorsed in any case. If they are studying in any Gurukul or Mutt, there is no bar on them to wear saffron or any other prescribed clothes.

  But look at the brazenness of some people, who have been appreciating the insanity of a burqa-clad girl, who was shouting an Islamic slogan and mocking scores of Hindu boys. Instead of hauling up that cranky girl for her highly uncouth and ugly behaviour, there are many who are full of praise for her dementia. Hindu boys should also have been scolded for raising slogans in retaliation to Burqa.

  At a time when the women are happily moving shoulder to shoulder with men. Can they be caged with their clumsy dress like Burqa or Hijab? After all, there has to be some semblance of discipline about dress in certain fields and there should be no exemption from that. For instance, if a Muslim woman is serving in the police or military, can she be allowed to wear Burqa, even it is integral to her religion? Similarly, A Muslim Advocate cannot claim to have the liberty to wear Burqa in the Courtroom in the name of her religious identity. The same is the case if a particular attire is prescribed in any company or institution, the same cannot be allowed to be diluted.  How can these Muslim girl-children be permitted to wear Burqa in a school, which has a prescribed dress code?

  However, let it be hastened to say that where there is no dress code, there should be complete freedom to wear anything of his/her choice subject to decency and acceptability in society. Like no one can insist on entering a temple, a mosque or a Gurdwara with their shoes on in the name of individual freedom. In some temples, men are allowed to enter only with bare chests and dhotis and in Gurudawaras one can enter only after covering the head. Nobody can be allowed to defy it in the name of freedom. In the same way, the food habits differ from place to place and person to person, but no one can claim to have the liberty of eating any and everything without having any regard to the sentiments of persons and the place.

   Hopefully, the responsible persons of the society of different religions will rise to the occasion to maintain peace and cordiality. Most of such problems and difficulties can be got over by enacting the Common Civil Code for the entire citizenry.