Sunday, February 23, 2025

Urdu a Divisive Language must be Discouraged


The UP Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath should be congratulated for side-stepping Urdu from the simultaneous translation in the assembly. There is hardly any doubt that except for script, there is no difference between Hindi and Urdu. Its syntax and numbers are the same as those in Hindi. It is only due to some fanatical Muslims that its script is a mix of Persian and Arabic, which has no justification whatsoever. Moreover, these fanatics made Urdu laden with Arabic and Persian words. They saw to it that Urdu remains exclusively the language of Muslims. It is a different matter altogether many non-Muslims have contributed to its literature.

In pre-partition days Aligarh Muslim University played a dirty role in driving away the Urdu from the people and the area where it was born. This university and the Urdu language provided the necessary arsenal for the creation of Pakistan. It was because of the hardened communal elements that Urdu was declared the official language of Pakistan although in no region Urdu was spoken. It was imposed on Sindhi, Punjabi, Pashto, Baluchi, Pasto, and Bangali and was declared to be the lingua franca of Pakistan. It was due to the imposition of Urdu on East Pakistan that Bengalis revolted and got a separate nation i.e. Bangladesh.  

The days are not far away when Pakistan will again get divided due mainly to the fundamentalists which is what Yogi Adityanath says them to be Kathmullas. Therefore, there is no need to shed tears for a divisive language like Urdu. The only way for it to survive is to accept the Devnagari script and eschew the obstinacy of packing it with Arabic and Persian words.

However, it must also be stated that English ought not to be encouraged. More importance and encouragement should be given to the promotion of Hindi rather than dialects like Awadhi, Bhojpuri, Bundeli and Braj.

No comments: